15 Shows Like Mindhunter | Know How A Criminal Mind Works With These Psychological Thrillers!!

shows like mindhunter

Psychoanalyzing the serial killers and applying the theories of behavioral science to get to the bottom of things can’t be done by just NOBODY! Not just anyone can profile a CRIMINAL! I’m no FBI Agent but a mere psychological thriller fan and you might have a subtle idea of what I’m going on about! Yeah, I am talking about Mindhunter! The series, which lasted for a total of 2 seasons with the third on indefinite hold! We never know if the series will make a reappearance but something has to fill the void created by Mindhunter! So, here I am, with shows like Mindhunter! 

Mindhunter was a huge hit, not only because of how well it was directed and produced but the idea that it was all real! Yeah, almost every crime in The Mindhunter series is real and based on the records of an FBI Agent who is portrayed as Holden Ford! But sadly Fincher, the director of the series has lots on his plate for which the series has been put on an indefinite HOLD!

Who doesn’t like to know how a criminal mind works, right? So here we are! Looking for shows similar to Mindhunter. Some of these shows, just like Mindhunter, are based on real-time crimes and that is what makes them so interesting! Wondering about who, how, and why gives a certain adrenaline rush! Here’s a list of shows based on criminal psychology that will surely remind you of our dear Agent Ford!

  1. Luther
  2. Manhunt
  3. American Crime Story
  4. Unbelievable
  5. Dexter
  6. The Act
  7. Hannibal
  8. Making A Murder
  9. Only Murders In The Building
  10. Conversations With A Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes
  11. Criminal Minds
  12. Fringe
  13. The Sinner
  14. Aquarius
  15. Broadchurch

Richard Speck, Montie Rissel, William Henry, Ed Kemper, etc are all actual serial killers who have been convicted for their heinous crimes! Let’s look at some other bunch of mass murders while looking at the list of shows like Mindhunter!

Also Read: 30+ TV Shows Like Ozark On Netflix, Amazon Prime, HBO, And Hulu!!

Mindhunter And Shows Like Mindhunter

shows like mindhunter
Genre: Crime, Drama, Psychological Thriller
Seasons- 2 (Epsidoes- 19)
Ratings: IMDb- 8.6/10
Image Source: TVguide

Mindhunter is an American psychological thriller based on real-time crimes compiled by FBI Agent John E. Douglas in his book “Mindhunter: Inside the FBI’s Elite Serial Crime Unit”. So now you know, it’s non-fiction! The series captures the initial years of the FBI’s BSU (Behavioral Science Unit) and criminal profiling.

The series made its worldwide debut on Netflix in October 2017 and season 2 of Mindhunter came two years later after the initial first season! Season 2 of Mindhunter premiered on Netflix in August 2019. 

David Fincher, the showrunner of the series, was engaged in too many projects which lead to the indefinite hold of season 3. This eventually resulted in the release of the cast from the show although the producer might “revisit” the series. Well! Everything is uncertain for the series but we shouldn’t be disheartened! There are many more gems like Mindhunter which we certainly shouldn’t miss watching! Here’s a list of them!

  1. Luther
  2. Manhunt
  3. American Crime Story
  4. Unbelievable
  5. Dexter
  6. The Act
  7. Hannibal
  8. Making A Murder
  9. Only Murders In The Building
  10. Conversations With A Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes
  11. Criminal Minds
  12. Fringe
  13. The Sinner
  14. Aquarius
  15. Broadchurch

Mindhunter Plot: Season 1 and Season 2

mindhunter plot
Source: The NYT

Mindhunter series depicts the initial year of the FBI’s Behavioral Science Unit when the department in the late 1970s. The mass murders, rape, and criminal acts were on a record high, and thus it’s essential to know how a criminal mind works!  

Thus comes the main leads of the series, FBI Agents Holden Ford (played by Jonathan Groff) and Bill Tench (played by Holt McCallany) around whom the whole series revolves. Ford and Tench, assisted by Psychology professor, Wendy Carr (played by Anna Torv), start their journey of research on criminal minds! 

It’s a perfect example of the “to catch the killer, become the killer” theory, which the protagonists apply while compiling their research on “how a criminal’s mind works?” By interviewing lots of serial killers and applying the principles of behavioral science, the agents are finally able to compile data that will further help them in their ongoing cases.

Season 1 of Mindhunter covers the time frame of 1977-80 where Ford and Tench are beginning their research on “how a criminal mind works?” These are the early years of criminal psychology where Tench, Ford, and psychologist Carr will interview serial killers to understand the psychology of a criminal and how it can be of help in their other cases!

Season 2 of the Mindhunter revolves around the Altlanta Murders of 1979-81, covering the time frame of 1980-81. Many real-time crimes are depicted in the second season and how they were solved in real life! 

Also Read: 50+ Crime Thriller TV Shows Like Criminal Minds On Netflix And Amazon Prime!!

Mindhunter Cast

mindhunter cast
Source: Showbiz Cheat Sheet

The cast of mind hunter has various recurring faces with the main leads staying as it is. The role of FBI Agent Holden Ford is played by Jonathan Groff, which is roughly based on John E. Douglas, the creator of the “Mindhunter: Inside the FBI’s Elite Serial Crime Unit”. Here’s a complete list of the cast from Mindhunter!

  • Jonathan Groff as Holden Ford
  • Holt McCallany as Bill Tench
  • Anna Torv as Wendy Carr
  • Hannah Gross as Debbie Mitford
  • Cotter Smith as Robert Shepard
  • Stacey Roca as Nancy Tench
  • Joe Tuttle as Gregg Smith
  • Michael Cerveris as Ted Gunn
  • Lauren Glazier as Kay Manz
  • Albert Jones as Jim Barney
  • Sierra McClain as Tanya Clifton
  • June Carryl as Camille Bell
  • Cameron Britton as Ed Kemper
  • Alex Morf as Mark Ocasek
  • Joseph Cross as Benjamin Barnwright
  • Marc Kudisch as Roger Wade
  • Michael Park as Peter Dean
  • George R. Sheffey as John Boylen
  • Duke Lafoon as Gordon Chambers
  • Peter Murnik as Roy Carver

More About Shows Like Mindhunter

There are many gems of psychological thrillers that will remind you of your favorite Mindhunter series! Some of them, just like Mindhunter, are based on real-time crimes and their mysteries. Let’s delve more into the world of criminal psychology today! Happy reading!

Luther

shows like mindhunter
Source: Amazon

Genre: Crime,

Seasons: 5 (Episodes- 20)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.4/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 88%

Luther, just like Mindhunter, is a perfect portrayal of criminals and criminal psychology! This series is about a remarkable detective, John Luther, who solves criminal cases and is in some ways, familiar to Holden Ford whose disturbed-dark side helps him to relate with the criminals and understand their psychology!

 If you like Mindhunter, then there’s no way you’re going to stop yourself from watching the fabulous acting of Idris in Luther!

Manhunt

shows like mindhunter
Source: Amazon

Genre: Drama, True Crime

Seasons: 2 (Episodes- 18)

Ratings: IMDb- 7.4/10

Manhunt is also a true crime story like Mindhunt but it revolves around the investigation of one particular case! This anthology series revolves around Criminal profiler, Jim Fitzgerald and The Unabomber “Ted Kaczynski”. 

Although some parts of it have been fictionalized, it is undeniable that the whole reality of the series is a true story!

American Crime Story

shows like mindhunter
Source: Amazon

Genre: Drama, True Crime, Anthology

Seasons: 3 (Episodes- 20)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.4/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 84%

The American Crime Story, an American anthology series that is based on true events! Every season of the series contains a new criminal case and the truths surrounding it. American Crime Story brings into the picture the case of O.J. Simpson and his murder and also the murder of Gianni Versace. 

If you want an actual crime story where the criminals and actors are curated according to the real-time happenings, then go for it! This series matches the description of Mindhunter in more ways than one!

Unbelievable

shows like mindhunter
Source: Heaven of Horror

Genre: Drama, True Crime

Seasons: 1 (Episodes- 8)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.4/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 98%

Unbelievable is a true crime story based on “An Unbelievable Story of rape”. This is the story of a girl, named Marie who gets accused of falsely reporting rape and the two detectives who will follow an unbelievable path to arrive at the hidden truths! 

Unbelievable covers many other sexual assault cases and if you want to read more details of them, you can refer to “An Unbelievable Story of rape” which also won a Pulitzer Prize. If you’re a Mindhunter fan, then obviously you’ll like this one too!

Dexter

shows like mindhunter
Source: ZEE5

Genre: Mystery, Crime, Psychological Thriller, Dark Comedy, Police Procedural

Seasons: 8 (Episodes- 96)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.6/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 71%

Dexter is an American Psychological thriller centering on a forensic technician, Dexter Morgan. Dexter is a bloodstain analyst helping the cops to reach the bloodiest of the serial killer, but here’s a catch! He’s one of them too, too perfect at that! 

Taking justice into his own hands, he only murders the worst of the criminals that have not been “charged” according to the crimes they have committed because of the loopholes in the system!  Although different from Holden, you will notice Dexter sharing some similarities with him! Watch the series to find what are they!

Also Read: 15 Shows Like Longmire | Must Watch Crime And Mystery Series!!

The Act

shows like mindhunter
Source: Amazon

Genre: Drama, True Crime

Seasons: 1 (Episodes-8)

Ratings: IMDb- 8/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 88%

The Act is a Hulu Original series starring two of the Oscar-nominated and winner actors! This is a true-crime series revolving around Gypsy Rose and her mother Dee Dee Blanchard. 

This is a dramatized version of a true crime story of an overprotective mother “suffering from Munchausen syndrome by proxy” and her murder. This series is worth a watch for true-crime lovers like Mindhunt.

Hannibal

shows like mindhunter
Source: WallpaperUp

Genre: Crime Drama, Psychological Horror, Psychological Thriller

Seasons: 3 (Episodes- 39)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.5/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 92%

Various nuances of Hannibal will remind of Mindhunter, especially the FBI and its behavioral science unit. But unlike Mindhunter, this series encompasses a whole new level of crime drama and psychological thrillers! 

The story revolves around an FBI profiler, Will Graham, and forensic psychiatrist, Hannibal Lecter (a cannibalistic serial killer). The suspense in Hannibal will keep the watchers on their toes! 

Making A Murder

shows like mindhunter
Source: IMDb

Genre: Documentary, True Crime

Seasons: 2 (Episodes- 20)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.6/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 84%

Making A Murder, just like Mindhunter, is a true-crime story based on a man who was falsely accused and convicted, Steven Avery. This series won a total of four “Primetime Emmy Awards” and is definitely worth a watch! 

The show covers the time during the false conviction and after the prosecution of Steven Harvey and his attorney’s efforts to prove him “not guilty!”

Only Murders In The Building

shows like mindhunter
Source: Rotten Tomatoes

Genre: Mystery, Comedy, Crime

Seasons: 1 (Episodes- 5)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.4/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 100%

You might be wondering what in the world is comedic fiction doing in the world of psychological thrillers, well that’s where you’re wrong! Only Murders In The Building adopts a different approach to solve murder mysteries, but it still is a crime story! Which by the way, received very good critical reviews! Do you know who’s in it? SELENA GOMEZ! 

Well, the story revolves around three people. Perfectly strangers to one another but share an obsession with true crime stories and happen to get entangled in one!

Conversations With A Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes

shows like mindhunter
Source: True Crime Obsessed

Genre: Documentary 

Seasons: 1 (Episodes- 4)

Ratings: IMDb- 7.8/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 56%

This is a must-watch documentary series for Mindhunter fans out there. Conversations With A Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes, covers the life and criminal history of a serial killer, Ted Bundy who was guilty of murdering more than 30 women.

This docu-series is a compilation of series of archival footage and interviews of Ted Bundy and his family. Many disturbing facts are laid out in the open as the serial killer himself explains criminal psychology. Ted was executed in 1989 for the heinous crimes he had committed and this doc-series was revealed on the 30th anniversary of his execution.

Criminal Minds

shows like mindhunter
Source: Amazon

Genre: Mystery, Police Procedural, Crime Drama, Thriller

Seasons: 15 (Episodes- 324)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.1/10 

Criminal Minds is a police procedural and crime-mystery series that will remind you of Mindhunter in more ways than one. Just like Mindhunter, the series is based on FBI criminal profilers who are members of the Behavioral Analysis Unit trying to use behavioral analysis to investigate the Unkown Subjects aka “Criminals”.

The most capable FBI profilers try to analyze the criminal’s mind before they find their next target! This is a very captivating series with 324 episodes to date!

Fringe

shows like mindhunter
Source: Wallpapers Flare

Genre: Sci-fi, Supernatural, Drama

Seasons: 5 (Episodes- 100)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.4/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 90%

Yeah, I know what you all are wondering at the moment! Isn’t it “what in the world is a sci-fi series doing in Mindhunter recommendations?” Well, that’s where you’re wrong! First of all, this series casts Anna Torv, one of the main leads of Mindhunter, who’s a part of the FBI! Rings bells now? Yeah, this story also has crime, mystery, and mind games!

This series revolves around the strange occurrences and the “parallel universe” whose mysteries are solved with the help of investigative techniques of the FBI! A true Mindhunter fan should definitely watch this one!

The Sinner

shows like mindhunter
Source: Medium

Genre: Thriller, Anthology, Crime Drama, Mystery

Seasons: 4 (Episodes- 24)

Ratings: IMDb- 7.9/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 90%

The Sinner revolves around a detective named Harry Ambrose who investigates the motivations behind the serious crimes that normal people do. Every Season contains a new mystery to be solved. If you’re a Mindhunter fan, don’t forget to watch this on!

The series has received many primetime Emmy nominations and the fourth season of The Sinner is about to premiere on 13, October 2021! So make sure don’t miss watching this masterpiece!

Aquarius

shows like mindhunter
Source: ALLPlayer

Genre: Period Drama, Crime

Seasons: 2 (Episodes- 26) 

Ratings: IMDb- 7.1/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 77%

Aquarius is a blend of true events and fiction revolving around an LAPD detective, Sam Hodiak. Much like Mindhunter, the series goes on uncovering the truth behind crimes.

The series is set in the1967 LA, where the detective with an undercover Narcotics officer will uncover the disappearance of Emma Karn. It is a very promising crime drama and I’m sure many of the Mindhunter fans will agree to this!

Broadchurch

shows like mindhunter
Source: Screen Rant

Genre: Mystery, Crime, 

Seasons: 3 (Episodes- 24)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.4/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 92%

Broadchurch, a crime drama, focuses on a teen murderer and detectives named, DI Alec Hardy and DS Ellie Miller. The story revolves around the death of an 11-year-old boy and the truth behind his death.

The first 2 seasons of the series are marred with suspicion and grief surrounding Danny’s death and investigating his killer. The third season however follows a different case. Hardy and Miller duo will certainly remind you of Holden and Tench and hence, this series is on the list of Mindhunter recommendations!

Also Read: 50 Mind-Bending Shows Like Black Mirror On Netflix To Stream Right Now!!

Wrapping Up

Mindhunter has been indefinitely put on hold and that has left the fans in a frenzy! Something has to fill in the void created by Mindhunter and so it will be filled by watching psychological thrillers similar to Mindhunter! There are many gems that will make you reminisce about your good old Mindhunter days and among those, Hannibal, Luther, and Dexter are a must-watch!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top