20+ Best Shows Like Supernatural | Fantastical Recommendations


As a teenager in denial, accepting the fact that your fourteen-year-long series has come to an end, is NO easy task! I mean imagine the agony when you’ve finally realized that your favorite pair of brothers won’t be going on their monster-hunting spree anymore! Yeah, I’m talking about Supernatural and the void it has created after it concluded in 2020. I feel you all and that’s why the search for a replacement is on! Well, I know no other series is on par with Supernatural, but let’s free a room for some other shows! Here’s a list of movies and shows like Supernatural!

Season 15 served as the last and the final one of Supernatural, premiering in October 2019 and concluding in 2020. The series went on for 327 episodes and we still haven’t had enough of it! But let’s face the moment of truth and move on just like Padalecki and Ackles walked out of our lives (in Supernatural of course!)

Here are a bunch of movies and shows that will definitely walk you down the path of history and make you remember your good-old Supernatural days! And you know what’s most special about this list? Well, the precious bond of brothers! Yeah! Some of the shows will definitely make you remember Sam and Dean! So here it goes! 

Top 10 Best Anime Like Psycho-Pass
Top 10 Best Anime Like Psycho-Pass
  1. The Vampire Diaries
  2. Once Upon A Time
  3. Crazyhead
  4. Person of Interest
  5. The X-Files
  6. Wynonna Earp
  7. Friday The 13th
  8. Cabin In The Woods
  9. My Bloody Valentine 3D
  10. The Craft
  11. Ghostbusters
  12. Buffy The Vampire Slayer
  13. Ghostbusters
  14. Crimson Peak

Keep reading to find out more about such series and why are they even on Supernatural recommendations! Happy Monster-hunting!

Also Read: 7 Shows Like Peaky Blinders | Best Period Dramas Of All Time

12 Series And TV Shows Like Supernatural

The Winchester brothers aren’t the only heroes in the supernatural world. There’s a long list of them just waiting to be discovered and we have just made that task easy for you guys! If your little heart starts rolling hearing about the unknown and the mystery, then go ahead and feed your hungry self with these action-packed supernatural TV shows!

The Dresden Files

shows like supernatural
Source: Amazon

Genre: Dark Fantasy, Occult Detective, Urban Fantasy

Seasons: 1 (Episodes- 12)

Ratings: IMDb- 7.7/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 58%

This series is packed with magic, wizards, and the hunt will definitely take you back in the Supernatural days of Sam and Dean hunting demons! By the way, this series is more than just bad guys and magic and wizardry, it’s a story of a detective which isn’t an ordinary one!

The story of The Dresden Files revolves around Harry Dresden who’s a detective by profession and a wizard too. Ordinary people aren’t aware of the danger that lurks and that’s where our Hero comes! This TV show is a must-watch if you like action, magic, and mystery!


shows like supernatural
Source: Amazon Adviser

Genre: Occult Detective, Police Procedural, Horror

Seasons: 6 (Episodes- 123)

Ratings: IMDb- 7.8/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 89%

Guardian, protecting humanity, and maintaining a balance! Here, I said it all. Isn’t that interesting enough to go on a watching spree? Well! Grimm is the show that will actually soothe your cravings for real supernatural stuff! This fantastical project is on par with Supernatural in more ways than one!

Grimm revolves around a homicide detective, who’s just not a detective by the way! He’s a guardian too who needs to maintain a balance between humanity and the mythological creatures (Wensen here). Nick (the detective) is accompanied on his monster-hunt with his friend and a detective partner! Seems like Sam and Dean right? (ignoring the fact that they aren’t brothers).


shows like supernatural
Source: Amazon

Genre: Sci-fi, Supernatural, Drama

Seasons: 5 (Episodes- 100)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.4/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 90%

Fringe is a perfect blend of fantastical and crime themes. Just like Supernatural, this show will tickle your fantasy-loving bones while adding different elements of other psychological thrillers! Fringe is often described as crossing the realm of The Twilight Zone, The X-files, and Altered States, and sometimes, finds itself in the middle of it! Confusing right? But only for those who haven’t watched it yet!

The show revolves around an FBI agent, a mad scientist, and his son, looking at the various aspects of fringe science! The themes of the parallel universe will definitely awe you and hence, this series has become a part of Supernatural recommendations!


shows like supernatural
Source: Amazon UK

Genre: Horror

Seasons: 1 (Episodes- 6)

Ratings: IMDb- 7.3/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 100%

No other Series recommendation will perfectly match Supernatural than Crazyhead! The pair of friends in the show will resemble Sam and Dean and you’ll be left wondering if they are the reincarnations of our favorite brothers or not!

Crazyhead revolves around a pair of best friends named Amy and Raquel who form a unique bond while dealing with fantastical stuff! This show is about a demon exorcising duo where one can see ghouls and others can hunt them down! Crazyhead is a MUST-WATCH!

Person of Interest

shows like supernatural
Source: Amazon

Genre: Action, Drama, Thriller, Police Procedural, Mystery, Sci-fi

Seasons: 5 (Episodes- 103)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.4/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 92%

Person of Interest is a supernatural crime-thriller drama series with many scientific elements. The show finds a place in the Supernatural recommendations because of the beautiful portrayal of characters and some similar elements of the storyline. 

This show revolves around the story of an unusual duo trying to prevent crimes with the help of a machine that can predict events even before they have happened! Seems like you’ve seen this kind of series before? Well, I know you haven’t! Watch this duo of an ex CIA agent and billionaire who have joined hands to control crime! I’m sure you’re going to love it!

The X-Files

shows like supernatural
Source: GeekWire

Genre: Mystery, Horror, Drama, Thriller, Sci-fi 

Seasons: 11 (Episodes- 218)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.6/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 74%

FBI agents solving paranormal cases? That doesn’t sound like such a good idea, right? Well, only if that was the case! The X-Files is all about “science meets mystery”, and that’s why it has made into the top recommendation of Supernatural!

This show revolves around two FBI Agents trying to open the file of cases that have never been solved before! This file is all about mystery and paranormal stuff that our grandmother warned us about and these two detectives go on their hunting, crime-solving spree to deal with fantastical stuff! 

Wynonna Earp

shows like supernatural
Source: Rotten Tomatoes

Genre: Drama, Fantasy, Supernatural

Seasons: 4 (Episodes- 49)

Ratings: IMDb- 7.5/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 92%

What happens when the outlaws you’ve finished all along come back? You send them back to their rightful place, right? That’s what Wynonna Earp is all about! Hunting criminals who have reincarnated and sending them back to hell! Hence, making on the list of Supernatural recommendations!

This show revolves around Wynonna Earp, the granddaughter of a great lawman who comes back to her old hometown to take on the job she has been destined for! The job of a demon protector!

Also Read: 15 Shows Like Mindhunter | Know How A Criminal Mind Works With These Psychological Thrillers!!


shows like supernatural
Source: VOX

Genre: Fiction, Supernatural, Horror, Action, Drama

Seasons: 5 (Episodes- 110)

Ratings: IMDb- 7.9/10

Angel is the spin-off from the series “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” and is a must-watch for all the fiction, fantasy, and supernatural-loving fans! 

The series revolves around a former Vampire, Angel, who has been punished for murdering a fellow of his own kind. On his journey to deal with his own demonic nature, Angel becomes a detective helping other doomed souls and while protecting humans from demons and otherworldly creatures! This is a fantastical series and I’m sure you will definitely love this one!

Warehouse 13

shows like supernatural
Source: Rotten Tomatoes

Genre: Sci-fi, Fantasy, Mystery

Seasons: 5 (Episodes- 64)

Ratings: IMDb- 7.6/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 82%

Warehouse 13 is an American fantasy-mystery series and it best suits our Supernatural recommendation list because this series brings out the beautiful elements of comradeship that we have seen in Sam and Dean!

The series revolves around two FBI agents who are assigned to retrieve the paranormal artifacts hidden in a secret warehouse in South Dakota. The agents couldn’t understand the importance of this mission who only thought of it as a punishment! They later come to realize how vital a task it is. 


series and TV shows like supernatural
Source: Rotten Tomatoes

Genre: Mystery, Police Procedural, Fiction, Occult Detective

Seasons: 6 (Episodes- 93)

Ratings: IMDb- 8.1/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 86%

I am sure everyone might have watched this one already which has become the talk of the town and has recently concluded with the final season! For those who haven’t watched this masterpiece yet, you should know that this series right here will definitely fill the void created by Supernatural!

Can a devil, a fallen angel become good again? Well, this series definitely covers many themes and the most prominent one here is the demon lord helping an ordinary human detective solve the criminal cases of the human realm! The devil certainly has some tricks up his sleeves helping the LAPD detective Decker. This show will definitely hook you up for a series-long all-nighter! Get your popcorn ready as once you start, you won’t be able to stop!!

The Vampire Diaries

series like supernatural
Source: Wallpaperflare

Genre: Mystery, Fantasy, Drama, Horror

Seasons: 8 (Episodes- 171)

Ratings: IMDb- 7.7/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 86%

The Vampire Diaries is another classic fantasy series and something tells me that you might have already watched this one too! I mean how can one miss the sexiest man in action! Yeah, talking about Ian Somerhalder! This series fits perfectly in Supernatural recommendation! Why? Apart from being an amazing fiction story, the plot contains an amazing pair of brothers!

This is a vampire story revolving around what happens when the supernatural world mixes up with the human realm! This is the story of human-vampire cohabitation mixed with action and lots of romance and drama!

Once Upon A Time

tv shows like supernatural
Source: What’s on Disney Plus

Genre: Fantasy, Action, Drama

Seasons: 7 (Episodes- 155)

Ratings: IMDb- 7.7/10 Rotten Tomatoes- 78%

Now this series will definitely make your childhood fantasy come to life! Can you believe this story has all the fictional elements of our classic childhood storybooks! Well, you’re in for a superb surprise on this one! 

The storyline revolves around the daughter of Snow White and the Prince Charming, Emma, the only hope to save the world from the curse of the evil queen! Emma is the only hope for all the fantasy world characters who have forgotten who they truly are. This is a beautiful and almost comic-like series and something in me says that you’re going to love this particular one right here! 

Also Read: 30+ TV Shows Like Ozark On Netflix, Amazon Prime, HBO, And Hulu!!

12 Movies Like Like Supernatural

movies like supernatural
Source: UploadVR

Sam and Dean have certainly leveled up our standards on how to evaluate and rate a perfect hero! But don’t worry, there are many fantastical characters that will suit your choosy palate! This movie’s list contains perfect and almost God-like heroes protecting the earth from evil-doers! If you’re a fan of Supernatural, then there’s no way you’re going to miss watching these masterpieces of movies! 

  1. The Others
  2. Onward
  3. Paranormal Activity
  4. The Grudge
  5. Friday The 13th
  6. Cabin In The Woods
  7. My Bloody Valentine 3D
  8. The Craft
  9. Ghostbusters
  10. Buffy The Vampire Slayer
  11. Crimson Peak

Also Read: 15 Shows Like Longmire | Must Watch Crime And Mystery Series!!

Wrapping Up Supernatural Recommendations 

Supernatural ended with the last and final episode of season 15 and we have to move on to some other splendid shows that are totally on par with it. TV series like Crazyhead and The X-Files will definitely make you remember your favorite Dark-fantasy series, Supernatural. Also, movies like Crimson Peak, Ghostbusters, and Friday The 13th are some of the top recommendations for Fantasy, fiction, and action lovers!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top